The 10 Best Rochester, NY Neighborhoods To Live In For 2019


We used science and data to determine which neighborhoods in Rochester are the best of the best.

Editor’s Note: We updated this article for 2019. This is our fifth time ranking the best neighborhoods to live in Rochester.
Best Neighborhoods In Rochester

Do you like your neighborhood?

Is it friendly, and where everyone knows their neighbors?

No matter if you live in the sticks or in an apartment building in downtown Rochester, you have a little pocket that you can call home. And each neighborhood is different.

Smaller neighborhoods usually have obvious benefits — less crime, a slower pace of life, and a lower cost of living. But not all Rochester neighborhoods are created equal. Some are better than others. But which ones?

Instead of relying on public opinion and speculation, we wanted to get the facts straight and find out which neighborhoods in Rochester are the best. If you’re in one of the places we’re about to highlight, odds are you know you’ve got it made.

Here are the best neighborhoods in Rochester for 2019:

  1. Park Avenue (Homes)
  2. Homestead Heights (Homes)
  3. Cobbs Hill (Homes)
  4. Browncroft (Homes)
  5. Corn Hill (Homes)
  6. Ellwanger-Barry (Homes)
  7. Culver-Winton (Homes)
  8. East Avenue (Homes)
  9. 19th Ward (Homes)
  10. Swillburg (Homes)

So what’s the best neighborhood to live in Rochester for 2019? According to the most recent census data, Park Avenue looks to be the best Rochester neighborhood to live in.

Read on to see how we determined the places around Rochester that deserve a little bragging rights or maybe you’re interested in the worst neighborhoods in Rochester.

Once you’re done, you can look at the bottom of the story for a complete chart of every neighborhood we looked at from best to worst.

For more New York reading, check out:

How we determined the best Rochester hoods in 2019

In order to rank the best neighborhoods in Rochester, we had to determine what criteria defines a “best”.

Using crime, census, and extrapolated BLS data, we arrived at the following set of criteria:

  • High incomes
  • Low unemployment rates
  • Low crime
  • High home prices
  • High population densities (A proxy for things to do)

We then ranked each neighborhood with scores from 1 to 32 in each category, where 1 was the best.

Next, we averaged the rankings for each neighborhood to create a best neighborhood index.

And finally, we crowned the neighborhood with the lowest best neighborhood index the “Best City Neighborhood In Rochester.” We’re lookin’ at you, Park Avenue.

Read on below to learn more about what it’s like to live in the best places Rochester, New York has to offer. Or skip to the end to see the list of all the neighborhoods in the city from best to worst.

Park Avenue Rochester, NY

Overall SnackAbility

8.5
/10

Population: 6,881
Rank Last Year: 1 (No Change)
Median Home Value: $159,055 (3rd best)
Median Income: $57,052 (3rd best)
More on Park Avenue: Homes For Sale | Data

Park Avenue and State Street Historic District is a national historic district located at Brockport in Monroe County, New York. The district encompasses 90 contributing buildings and 1 contributing site in a predominantly residential section of Brockport. The district developed between about 1830 and 1930, and includes buildings in a variety of architectural styles including Greek Revival, Gothic Revival, Italianate, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival. Located in the district is the separately listed First Presbyterian Church. Other notable buildings include houses dated to the 1830s and 1840s.

Overall SnackAbility

8
/10

Population: 4,022
Rank Last Year: 9 (Up 7)
Median Home Value: $79,700 (16th best)
Median Income: $52,330 (4th best)
More on Homestead Heights: Homes For Sale | Data

Homestead Heights is located in northeast Rochester. It is bordered on the west by Goodman Street, on the north by Clifford Avenue, on the south by Bay Street, and on the east by Culver Road, which is also the border between the city and the town of Irondequoit. The neighborhood is a mix of residential and commercial. Real estate values are higher on the eastern end of the neighborhood near the Irondequoit border. The neighborhood is approximately 2214 miles west of the Irondequoit Bay.

Cobbs Hill Rochester, NY

Overall SnackAbility

8.5
/10

Population: 1,495
Rank Last Year: 2 (Down 1)
Median Home Value: $178,800 (1st best)
Median Income: $83,062 (1st best)
More on Cobbs Hill: Homes For Sale | Data

Cobbs Hill Reservoir is a reservoir located in Cobbs Hill Park in Rochester, New York, United States. The reservoir is used to supply drinking water to the city of Rochester. The source of the water is Hemlock Lake, which lies 30 miles due south of and 400 feet higher elevation than Rochester.

Browncroft Rochester, NY

Overall SnackAbility

8
/10

Population: 3,392
Rank Last Year: 6 (Up 2)
Median Home Value: $123,550 (6th best)
Median Income: $59,790 (2nd best)
More on Browncroft: Homes For Sale | Data

The Browncroft Historic District is a national historic district located in the Browncroft Neighborhood of Rochester, New York. The district contains 518 contributing buildings, two contributing sites, two contributing objects, and two contributing structures over 116 acres. It includes 417 residential properties constructed between 1914 and World War II.

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 2,460
Rank Last Year: 8 (Up 3)
Median Home Value: $165,533 (2nd best)
Median Income: $37,973 (11th best)
More on Corn Hill: Homes For Sale | Data

Overall SnackAbility

8
/10

Population: 3,991
Rank Last Year: 6 (No Change)
Median Home Value: $117,657 (8th best)
Median Income: $49,988 (6th best)
More on Ellwanger-Barry: Homes For Sale | Data

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 7,664
Rank Last Year: 5 (Down 2)
Median Home Value: $99,225 (11th best)
Median Income: $51,785 (5th best)
More on Culver-Winton: Homes For Sale | Data

East Avenue Rochester, NY

Overall SnackAbility

8
/10

Population: 6,623
Rank Last Year: 4 (Down 4)
Median Home Value: $134,240 (5th best)
Median Income: $46,852 (8th best)
More on East Avenue: Homes For Sale | Data

East Avenue Historic District is a national historic district located at Rochester in Monroe County, New York. The district consists of a series of large 19th and early 20th century homes, houses of worship, meeting houses, and museums. It contains approximately 700 structures. Notable structures in the district include the Hiram W. Sibley House, home of Hiram Sibley; Edward E. Boynton House, Rochester’s only work by Frank Lloyd Wright; the Culver House, moved to its present site in 1906; and the Strong-Todd House, once occupied by Henry A. Strong.

Overall SnackAbility

6
/10

Population: 20,696
Rank Last Year: 15 (Up 6)
Median Home Value: $69,691 (20th best)
Median Income: $36,499 (14th best)
More on 19th Ward: Homes For Sale | Data

Swillburg Rochester, NY

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 1,889
Rank Last Year: 11 (Up 2)
Median Home Value: $99,420 (10th best)
Median Income: $45,023 (9th best)
More on Swillburg: Homes For Sale | Data

This wedge-shaped piece of the city is bordered by S. Clinton Avenue on the west, Field St on the south, and Interstate 490 on the east. The neighborhood received its moniker when a 19th-century Rochester pig farmer utilized the area to collect swill for his swine. The area has one of the highest rates of homeownership in the city.

Putting A Bow On Our Analysis Of The Best Neighborhoods In Rochester

If you’re measuring the neighborhoods in Rochester where crime is low and everyone wants to live, this is an accurate list.

As we mentioned earlier, the neighborhoods in Rochester aren’t all good. Best takes the title of the worst neighborhood to live in Rochester.

We ranked the neighborhoods from best to worst in the chart below.

For more New York reading, check out:

Detailed List Of The Best Neighborhoods To Live In Rochester For 2019

Rank Neighborhood Population Home Value Median Income
1 Park Avenue 6,881 $159,055 $57,052
2 Homestead Heights 4,022 $79,700 $52,330
3 Cobbs Hill 1,495 $178,800 $83,062
4 Browncroft 3,392 $123,550 $59,790
5 Corn Hill 2,460 $165,533 $37,973
6 Ellwanger-Barry 3,991 $117,657 $49,988
7 Culver-Winton 7,664 $99,225 $51,785
8 East Avenue 6,623 $134,240 $46,852
9 19th Ward 20,696 $69,691 $36,499
10 Swillburg 1,889 $99,420 $45,023
11 Pearl-Meigs-Monroe 3,036 $91,433 $35,997
12 Charlotte 6,806 $90,714 $36,917
13 South Wedge 3,406 $117,900 $36,400
14 Atlantic-University 1,762 $102,100 $39,538
15 Northland-Lyceum 4,774 $72,580 $34,388
16 Highland 5,792 $85,320 $37,308
17 Central Business District 4,457 $56,250 $35,651
18 Beechwood 8,913 $65,964 $30,428
19 Maplewood 17,663 $70,009 $34,491
20 Strong 4,446 $72,875 $48,747
21 North Marketview Heights 4,924 $39,200 $22,091
22 Genesee-Jefferson 4,523 $43,871 $22,632
23 Plymouth-Exchange 3,471 $41,380 $19,068
24 Susan B Anthony 755 $147,750 $19,618
25 Lyell-Otis 9,016 $39,692 $27,936
26 South Marketview Heights 3,378 $46,800 $20,220
27 Mayor’s Heights 2,522 $96,980 $18,939
28 Dutchtown 3,302 $39,343 $21,620
29 Upper Falls 6,838 $27,756 $16,813
30 Charles House 2,575 $55,550 $20,658
31 Edgerton 7,051 $23,855 $18,831
32 Best 514 $62,567 $18,122

About Chris Kolmar

Chris Kolmar has been in the real estate business for almost ten years now. He originally worked for Movoto Real Estate as the director of marketing before founding HomeSnacks.

He believes the key to finding the right place to live comes down to looking at the data, reading about things to do, and, most importantly, checking it out yourself before you move.

If you've been looking for a place to live in the past several years, you've probably stumbled upon his writing already.

You can find out more about him on LinkedIn or his website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *